Mahomes Is Still the Answer, and It Isn't Close
Every September someone tries to take the crown. Every January the crown stays put.
We do this every year. A quarterback puts together a hot month, the stat sheets light up, and the internet decides the throne is empty. Then January comes and we remember what the job actually is.
The job is the fourth quarter
Regular-season efficiency numbers are useful. They're also the easiest numbers in football to inflate: a couple of blowouts, a soft stretch of the schedule, a coordinator who hasn't been figured out yet. What doesn't inflate is what happens when the other team knows you have to throw and you do it anyway.
That's the Mahomes argument, and it's the only one I need.
"But the supporting cast…"
Yes. Some years the receiver room has been thinner than you'd want for a franchise quarterback. That's the point. Great quarterbacks don't need perfect conditions; they make the conditions irrelevant.
Rank the résumé, not the highlight.
Where I'll give ground
I'll concede that Josh Allen has closed the gap more than anyone expected, and that Lamar Jackson at his best might be the most unstoppable player in the sport for a quarter at a time. Chris will tell you all about it on Monday.
But best isn't a quarter at a time. Best is who you'd pick with the season on the line. I still pick 15.
Where I have him: QB1 in my rankings this week. Tell me I'm wrong in the Takes section.
Daniel Coale
Daniel Coale co-hosts Sideline Summit on the Belly Up Media Network, breaking down the NFL and NBA every week with Chris Coulter and Antonio Perez.
Newsletter
Get the weekly
New articles, the latest episode and pick'em standings. One email a week.
Daniel's latest takes
Co-host · NFL & NBA · Sep 28
“Jalen Hurts finishes the season as a top-5 QB.”
Co-host · NFL & NBA · Sep 25
“Running backs are back. Every contender this year has a bell cow.”
Keep reading
How We Rank Quarterbacks (and Why We Disagree)
Three hosts, three philosophies, one leaderboard.
DCDaniel Coale· Sep 16
The Bills' Window Isn't Closing. It's Wide Open.
Stop writing the obituary. This roster was built for January.
CCChris Coulter· Sep 25
Power Rankings, Week 4: The Mushy Middle
The top is clear-ish. Spots 8 through 20 are chaos.
DCDaniel Coale· Sep 24
The conversation Live