Skip to content
PreviewEpisodes load live from the podcast feed. Takes, rankings, articles and clips are sample content until the hosts publish their own.

How We Rank Quarterbacks (and Why We Disagree)

Three hosts, three philosophies, one leaderboard.

DCDaniel CoaleCo-host · NFL & NBASeptember 16, 2026 · 5 min readNFL

Our QB rankings disagree every week, and that's the point. Here's how each of us thinks about it.

Daniel: the film

I care about what a quarterback does after the defense takes away his first read. Pocket movement, anticipation, off-script decisions. Stats come second.

Chris: the numbers

Chris weights EPA per play and success rate heavily, then adjusts for supporting cast. His rankings move the most week to week.

Antonio: the "who do you want" test

Antonio's question is simple: with the season on the line, who do you want? His rankings move the least.

Compare all three on the QB rankings board, then build your own.

DC

Daniel Coale

Daniel Coale co-hosts Sideline Summit on the Belly Up Media Network, breaking down the NFL and NBA every week with Chris Coulter and Antonio Perez.

More from Daniel

Newsletter

Get the weekly

New articles, the latest episode and pick'em standings. One email a week.

Free. Unsubscribe any time with one click.

The conversation Live

Daniel's latest takes

Keep reading